Mike O'Connor of Australia's Courier Mail feels that World Youth Day isn't worth the $150-210 million it will cost to stage an event for a religious group that represents 25% of the population.
O'Connor wonders "how in a world of poverty and want, the Church can justify the expenditure of $150 million to stage a giant get-together."
"In holding World Youth Day, the Church obviously hopes to engage with young people who show little or no interest in organised religion," writes O'Connor. "Walk into any church in Brisbane next Sunday and you will see very few people under the age of 30 in the pews. The problem is real but I very much doubt if World Youth Day is going to suddenly fill the churches with teenagers. It might give all who attend a feeling of belonging and relevance for a few days but it is not going to reverse the decline in the Church's appeal in this country or elsewhere."
O'Connor makes a common mistake - that of thinking that because he doesn't see young people in Church on Sunday morning that they are not engaged in the Church. This is a common misconception. In doing research for my book "Young and Catholic: The Face of Tomorrow's Church," it became clear that youth and young adults who stay up late on Saturday evening aren't likely to be seen at Sunday's 8 a.m. Mass. However, youth-oriented Masses, are quite popular here in the U.S. and in Australia by groups such as NET Ministries, and LifeTeen. It may come as a surprise to O'Connor, but those offered through LifeTeen Australia often take place on either Saturday or Sunday evening. In fact, the Sunday evening Mass is becoming the Mass of choice for young people even at many local parishes.
LifeTeen Australia at Castle Hill, for example, has more than 500 teens every Sunday night at 6 p.m. So, it would be quite natural not to see these young people at Church on Sunday morning. Here's a blog entry on LifeTeen in Australia.
As for the comment regarding the Church spending money, this is the similar argument that gets used whenever the Church decides to build a new Cathedral. It reminds me of Judas' complaint (in John 12:1-8) when Mary uses costly oil to anoint Christ's feet.
Judas, who kept the purse for the poor, argues that the money could have been put to better use.
Jesus' response to Judas is "Let her alone; she has kept this for the day of My burial. For the poor you have with you always, but Me you do not have always."
It is hard, perhaps, to gauge the lasting impact of World Youth Day upon a country and those who attend, but the event is set up almost like a mini-Easter, with the Way of the Cross on Friday, Saturday's pilgrimage, and Sunday's final Mass. It is, at its very core, an encounter with Christ.
I've experienced two World Youth Days. One immediate result that came from World Youth Day in Toronto was the Canadian television network Salt + Light. I recall speaking with Milwaukee's Archbishop Timothy Dolan at WYD in Cologne. As former rector of the North American College in Rome, he told me that in reading the essays of incoming seminarians, WYD played a pivotal role in their discernment of their religious vocation in a significant number of applications.
Yes, the Church hopes for a revival wherever WYD is held, but fundamentally youth come from around the world at the invitation of the Holy Father to encounter Jesus Christ.
"I would hope that the World Youth Day would strengthen the faith of young Christians and that that would be represented, in one way amonst others, by an increased frequency in their attendance at mass and prayerfulness, trying to build lifelong marriages, following the church's teachings in all sorts of ways," said Cardinal George Pell. "I would be surprised if we don't have a bit of a bounce for at least a couple of years afterwards in the numbers of young men coming into the priesthood and your women wanting to devote themselves to the Catholic Church and even things like the number of young Catholics who want to become Catholic teachers."